Game Master's Journey 93 - Fixing D&D's Broken XP & Advancement System

Although I’m a fan of how Dungeons & Dragons fifth edition uses xp budgets to build encounters, the system for handing out experience for character advancement is unfortunately broken. I describe the problem and offer a solution. I also discuss handing out xp for roleplaying and traps.

Episode 82 – To XP or Not to XP, Random Encounters & Should the Players Always Win?

Episode 84 – XP & Random Encounters Feedback

How Encounter-Based XP is Broken & My Proposed Solution

I think it’s interesting that in a recent AMA on Reddit, Mike Mearls said he doesn’t hand out xp, but just levels the PCs every other session.

Combat Encounters On-the-Fly

Here’s a gem from Mike Mearls from that same AMA. If he needs a quick fight for the PCs on-the-fly, he does the following:

If he wants multiple opponents, he throws no more than 3-5 monsters/NPCs at the party with a CR ½ or less of the party’s level. I think something to keep in mind here is economy of action (as far as deciding how many to use in the 3-5 range). Generally speaking, less NPCs than PCs will be an easier fight (although multiattack can alter this), and more NPCs than PCs will be a difficult, or even deadly, fight. It all comes down to how many actions each side has.

If he wants a single opponent, he uses one with a CR equal to or less than the party’s level. 

How to Support the Podcast

Visit our Support page to learn the many ways you can help us out and help support the show.

Music Credits

©2016 Starwalker Studios LLC